|
Harry
S. Crump
Originally published in
the March/April 1988 issue.
Author: Frederick Finch
One
criticism sometimes made about judicial appointments is that the
judge’s range of experience is too narrow. That statement is
one that can’t be made about Harry Seymour Crump, newly
appointed Judge of Hennepin County District Court, however.
Judge Crump’s background includes service as a practicing
attorney, a civil rights enforcement officer, an administrative
law judge, and a member of the Minnesota Public Utilities
Commission. He’s worked for the federal, state, and local
governments. And, he’s a registered pharmacist!
Judge Crump was
born December 29, 1937, in Chicago, Illinois. He moved around as
a boy, living in Louisiana, Mississippi, and Milwaukee,
Wisconsin. He graduated from Chicago Vocational High School,
graduating sixth out of a class of 415. Judge Crump’s aptitude
for math and science convinced him that he wanted to study
engineering and physics. So, he enrolled at Wilson Junior
College, where he received an Associate of Arts degree in
engineering and physics. It was there that one of his chemistry
teachers, who was also a pharmacy professor, interested him in
being a pharmacist. As a result, Judge Crump enrolled in the
pharmacy program at the University of Illinois Medical Center.
He received a B.S. degree in chemistry and pharmacy, a five-year
degree program, and became a registered pharmacist!
But history
repeated itself. While he was in pharmacy school, Judge Crump
took a class in pharmacy law from a professor who was a
professor of pharmacy and a lawyer. He loved the course, got an
"A", and got the "itch" to go to law school.
Judge Crump
enrolled in the evening law school program at DePaul University
in Chicago. After he enrolled, he was told that it was more
prestigious to receive a law degree from the day program at the
law school, so he transferred to the day program even though he
continued to take all of his classes at night. Nothing in the
law school’s rules prevented a day student from taking night
courses! Crump was on the Dean’s list, was selected for law
review, and graduated in the top quarter of his class in 1974.
Labor law was
one of the courses that interested Judge Crump, and he
interviewed for a position with the National Labor Relations
Board [NLRB] as a staff attorney. A week before he graduated,
Judge Crump was offered a job with the NLRB and given a choice
of moving to Washington, D.C., or Minneapolis. Judge Crump chose
Minneapolis. He then practiced law as a staff attorney with the
Eighteenth Regional Office of the NLRB in Minneapolis.
In 1975, Crump
accepted a position as the assistant to the director of the St.
Paul Civil Rights Department. He found that the skills he had
learned at the NLRB were valuable in this position. Judge Crump
established case handling standards and procedures, trained
investigators, and eliminated a backlog of cases, which was
crippling the agency. Judge Crump is proud of his work to
establish time standards for case handling, which enabled
investigators to get cases processed on time and provided the
management tools to monitor employee performance and justify the
staff needed to get the job done.
In 1978, Judge
Crump became a Hearing Examiner with the Minnesota Office of
Hearing Examiners. In 1983, the job title was changed to
Administrative Law Judge, and the department was renamed the
Office of Administrative Hearings. Administrative law judges
conduct hearings on rulemaking and contested cases under the
Minnesota Administrative Procedure Act. Judge Crump heard a wide
variety of cases in all areas of administrative law, but he was
frequently assigned to cases where he could use his technical
background, including environmental cases and contested cases in
the health sciences.
In this
position, once again, a fortuitous occurrence led to a new
career path. Judge Crump was assigned to hear a utility rate
case. He quickly developed an expertise on this complex and
complicated subject. As a result, he was increasingly assigned
to cases in this area. One of these was a case involving NSP’s
request for a rate increase to reflect the estimated $780
million cost of decommissioning the utility’s nuclear plants
at Monticello and Prairie Island at the end of their useful
lives. After months of hearings and thousands of pages of
testimony, Crump allowed NSP to establish a sinking fund, using
revenues from investments as well as rate payments to fund the
costs of decommissioning. Judge Crump’s ruling was adopted by
the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission.
Judge Crump’s
increasing knowledge about regulation of public utilities led to
his appointment by Governor Perpich to a position on the Public
Utilities Commission, the agency charged with regulating utility
rates and service. Judge Crump later served as chair of that
commission.
Judge Crump was
appointed a Hennepin District Court Judge and sworn in on
December 1, 1987. He replaced Judge Robert Schumacher, who was
elevated to the Court of Appeals.
Judge Crump has
an active life away from the law, as well. He lives with his
wife, Alice, and two of his seven children in Minneapolis. He is
an avid skier and serves as an instructor in first aid and
rescue techniques with the National Ski Patrol. And, the end of
winter doesn’t end Judge Crump’s outdoor activities. He is a
certified scuba diver and teaches wind surfing on Twin Cities
area lakes. He also admits to being a modestly good golfer.
Being an avid
sportsman hasn’t prevented Judge Crump from participating in
public-service activities. He’s been an active member of the
St. Paul Urban League; a board member of a group helping
minorities with chemical dependency problems; and an active
member of the Hennepin County Bar Association/Legal Advice
Clinics, Ltd. [LAC], where he served as a clinic lawyer seeing
three or four low-income clients one night per month on a pro
bono basis. Judge Crump has also served on LAC’s board of
directors for many years. He says that one of his few regrets
about becoming a judge is that he has had to give up his
participation in many of these groups because of conflict of
interest problems or because his presence on the governing board
might be construed as participation in the organization’s
fund-raising activities—something that is forbidden to judges
as the Code of Judicial Conduct is interpreted in Minnesota.
So what is it
like being a District Court Judge after years of experience as
an Administrative Law Judge? "I’d be lying if I said it
wasn’t a big change," responds Judge Crump. "I think
my experience deciding cases at the Public Utilities Commission,
as an Administrative Law Judge, and as a hearing examiner at the
NLRB has helped, but so much of being a District Court Judge can’t
compare with anything else."
For example,
there’s arraignment court. "A judge really has no control
over the volume you’ve got to handle," Judge Crump
observed. "Some days you get over 200 cases. Many people
don’t have attorneys, and some really don’t understand what’s
happening to them, but you’ve got to find some way of
disposing of all those cases without sacrificing fairness. The
average person has little contact with the courts." Crump
continued, "I try to be accessible to people, to try to
help them understand what’s going on in words and concepts
they can understand."
One problem that
troubles Judge Crump is that of the mentally ill who have fallen
through the cracks in the system. "One day I had three or
four people before me on theft and disorderly conduct charges.
They didn’t have enough orientation to their situation to
understand the court proceedings or what was happening to them
no matter how much explanation they received. They really weren’t
competent to be on the street, but they weren’t sick enough to
be committed. We really need to find a way to deal with these
people."
Judge Crump says
that to him, fairness is the single most important aspect of
being a judge: "I want to be thought of as a judge whose
background is based on fairness. I want the prosecutor, the
defendant, and the victim all to perceive the handling of a
criminal matter as fair, even if they don’t happen to agree
with the result."
One thing that
has impressed Judge Crump since his appointment is the
assistance he has received from other judges. "It is really
a pleasure on finding out how much help other judges are willing
to give. Everybody has been helpful in talking over problems
with procedures and rulings on tough issues. I’m responsible
for my own rulings, but it’s nice to be able to talk over a
problem with another judge who’s seen the problems
first-hand."
By the way,
Judge Crump still keeps his hand in the pharmacy, at least in a
way. He lectures at the University of Minnesota pharmacy school
on law and pharmacy.
|